Hyphen-Nation: Racial Impersonation
and the Performance of Hyphenated Americanness

alternative archives

My research explores how minoritarian performances of racial, ethnic, and national identities expanded definitions of U.S. Americanness. In my monograph, entitled Hyphen-Nation: Racial Impersonation and the Performance of Hyphenated Americanness, these performances are racial impersonations by U.S. American entertainers of Irish, Chinese, Eastern European Jewish, and African descent from the late nineteenth to the early twentieth century. The book views these “hyphenated impersonations” as tools for social critique and identity formation, using them to theorize hyphenation during a peak period of U.S. immigration. I show how impersonation forged dynamic relationships between the racial identities portrayed and the performers’ own identities, arguing that this fluidity in performance challenged fixed notions of hyphenation in society more broadly. Indeed, I argue that impersonation served as a platform to show that hyphenation is not a fixed identity marker but rather a dynamic process of identity formation adaptable to specific contexts and relations. Such situational understanding of hyphenation results in a new conception of the nation at large. This “hyphen-Nation,” as I phrase it, is not simply “a nation of immigrants” but a nation that understands hyphenation as a situational process of identity production in an effort to negotiate the complexity of its socio-political structure.

(Image, from top left to bottom right: Kate Elinore, postcard, January 7, 1907, Elinore Sisters Vaudeville Act Papers, Rush Rhees Library, Rare Books, Special Collections, and Preservation, University of Rochester; Lee Tung Foo in Scottish Highland costume, publicity photograph, White Studio, 1929, California History Room, Picture Collection, Portraits, California State Library; Eddie Cantor in blackface, publicity photograph, Apeda Studio, undated, Eddie Cantor Papers, B 47, Charles E. Young Research Library’s Special Collections, University of California Los Angeles; Aida Overton Walker as “Salome,” Schomburg Center for Research in Black Culture, The New York Public Library)